Critical Information Literacy

Call for Panelists: ARLIS/NA 2027

Expressions of interest are invited for the panel At the Confluence of Research and Making, due December 4, 2026.

Information literacy is usually understood as the ability to find, evaluate, and use information well. Critical information literacy keeps those abilities but widens the question. Students still judge individual sources, but they also examine the conditions under which information becomes visible, credible, and authoritative: who produces it, whose interests shape how it is framed, which institutions and systems carry it to an audience, and why some accounts come to be trusted while others are overlooked.

Authority is not simply a quality that a source possesses. It is conferred by publishers and institutions, by professional communities, by classification schemes, by search systems, and by platforms. Seeing information this way does not make students cynical about evidence. It makes them more precise about where credibility comes from and what it depends on.

These relationships are also embedded in the systems through which information is organized and retrieved. Library classifications and subject headings establish categories of description; search interfaces determine which records are discoverable; and recommendation systems rank and circulate materials according to criteria that are not always visible to users. Critical information literacy asks students to examine these arrangements as historically and institutionally produced rather than neutral mechanisms of access.

In art and design education

Dr. Dan Williford’s work in this area is shaped by teaching at an art and design college, where students are makers as well as researchers. The images, texts, objects, and media they produce enter the systems they study. For them, the conditions under which information becomes authoritative are also the conditions under which their own work will be seen, interpreted, and credited.

Dr. Williford brings critical information literacy together with media studies. Dr. Williford draws on Stuart Hall’s encoding/decoding model to examine how media texts encode preferred meanings and how audiences may accept, negotiate, or oppose them. Semiotics and adaptation theory provide related but distinct approaches to representation and the transformation of texts across media and historical periods. Platforms and generative AI make these questions more pressing, raising new questions about sources, authorship, and the use of other people’s work.

In library instruction

Sessions are developed with faculty, discussion-based, and built around contemporary case studies. Recent instruction has used debates about artistic expression, political speech, and social media. The emphasis is on understanding how authority operates, not on prescribing what students should think. See Ringling Library.

Publications

Williford, Dan. “From Maker to Meaning-Maker: Rethinking Art Students as Cultural Researchers Through Critical Information Literacy.” Art Documentation: Journal of the Art Libraries Society of North America. Forthcoming.

This article examines how critical information literacy can help art and design students understand their creative practice as a form of research and cultural knowledge production. It considers the relationships among visual authorship, representation, appropriation, citation, and ethical responsibility, and positions students not only as makers of creative work but also as participants in the production and circulation of knowledge.

Williford, Dan. “Critical Information Literacy in Higher Education: An Evolution in Theory, Practice, and Assessment.” Communications in Information Literacy 20, no. 1 (2026): 106–126. https://doi.org/10.15760/comminfolit.2026.20.1.6

A critical synthesis of scholarship on critical information literacy in higher education from 2015 to 2026, drawing on forty-eight peer-reviewed publications from 2020 to 2026. Building on Eamon Tewell’s framework, the article traces developments in theory, pedagogy, digital and political engagement, reflexive critique, and assessment. It argues that the field’s future depends on justice-oriented approaches to assessment, attention to labor and institutional accountability, and closer study of algorithmic systems and generative AI.

Williford, Daniel. “Teaching Critical Information Literacy through Popular Culture: A Media Studies Approach Using the Oz Texts.” Journal of Information Literacy 19, no. 2 (2025): 104–111. https://doi.org/10.11645/19.2.784

A project report on a fifteen-week undergraduate curriculum for art and design students that integrates critical information literacy with media studies. Four versions of The Wizard of Oz, from L. Frank Baum’s novel (1900) to Wicked (2024), serve as case studies in which students examine authority, bias, and power through encoding and decoding, semiotics, adaptation theory, and algorithmic critique.

Conference Presentations and Panels

At the Confluence of Research and Making: Critical Information Literacy for Cultural Producers. Panel chaired by Dan Williford. 55th Annual Conference of the Art Libraries Society of North America (ARLIS/NA), Portland, Oregon, April 4–7, 2027. Forthcoming.